Browse Venue prices, photos and 7 reviews, with a rating of 4.7 out of 5. A favorite of Cape May locals and visitors alike, PSI is a BYOB establishment offering a la carte dining along with a variety of seasonal tasting menus throughout the year. Fine dinning at its best. The Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is one of Cape May's most historic and iconic homes. Free self ⦠Popular Hotel Amenities and Features. The Peter Shields offers a la carte dining along with a four course chef’s tasting menu. This is a BYOB and we appreciated the reminder when...we received a complimentary reservation reminder.More, We have been dining at Peter Shields Inn for at least 30 years. Especially as the BYOB policy enabled me to bring a bubbly sans the usual 300%-plus restaurant mark-up. First-class service of exquisitely prepared dishes on a porch overlooking the Atlantic Ocean is hard to beat. We will definitely come back here for a special evening. The porch was a great place to catch a sunset. BYOB or local winery wines can be purchased. Prices were always high but dinner was worth the price. piano player taking requests which we also loved. A 5 star experience every time. Rates from R4 219. Hotels near Finishing Touches of Cape May, Tripadvisor Plus Subscription Terms & Conditions. Fine dining well done. My hubs and I will definitely come back in the future! Just an FYI, it is BYOB as it doesn't have a liquor license. Best in Cape May. Peter Shields Inn is Cape May's most romantic bed and breakfast. We had reservations at Peter Shields Inn where we had previously enjoyed a delicious dinner. With a stay at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant in Cape May, you'll be close to Mid-Atlantic Center for the Arts and Cape May Lighthouse. Sumptuous, leisurely breakfasts are included with your stay as well as leisurely afternoon "wine and cheese." Many nights there is a piano player to enhance the rooms. It's a beautiful house and very well maintained.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. My friend and I enjoyed both of our appetizers. The staff are always personable,...professional and informative. This place is a BYOB so that helps keep the cost down. Menu & Reservations Make Reservations . Another great experience and we are certain to be back. With a stay at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant in Cape May, you'll be within a 15-minute drive of Sunset Beach and Poverty Beach. Can a vegan person get a good meal at this restaurant? My husband had the pork chop, which he loved. We found the Inn and staff warm and welcoming. Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Enjoy seafood specialties that include Seared Day Boat Scallops, South African Lobster Tail, and our signature Lobster Crab Cakes. Of course, you need a QR app to scan the code. Specialties: Sit on our front porch to watch dolphins and birds navigate the Atlantic coastline. There was a live...piano player taking requests which we also loved. ample for 2 people. The meal did not disappoint and confirmed what everyone was saying about how fabulous the restaurant was. We enjoyed some delicious salad appetizers before our entrees of Beef Short Ribs and a Pork Chop. Menu items vary, but always of excellent quality and tastefully presented. Pricey for me but certainly worth every penny. Beautiful plating ... appealing to eyes. This beach inn is within close proximity of Nature Center of Cape May and Emlen Physick Estate. 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ, 08204, United States of America, 800-246-8357 I think I'll recommend it. Entree was delicious and the veggies just melted in your mouth. Compare prices and find the best deal for the Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant in Cape May (New Jersey) on KAYAK. It's a beautiful house and very well maintained. We were staying at the Inn and had dinner reservations. There have been many changes over time and not all for the better. Are you sure you want to delete this question? Definitely pricey, but worth every penny...probably the one of the best meals I have ever had at a restaurant. Perfect in every way. Zagat rated restaurant on premise provides American breakfast included in your stay. We noticed that you're using an outdated browser. We traveled to Cape May for our 47th anniversary in February. Enjoy the beautiful Cape May ocean views from our porch. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. We really enjoyed our food... lots of flavors going on in each plate. As always the service, food and experience were outstanding. Poverty Beach is minutes away. Peter Shields Inn is Cape May's most romantic bed and breakfast. Start Saving Today! Sumptuous, leisurely breakfasts are included with your stay as well as leisurely afternoon "wine and cheese." It was overcooked plus was sprinkled with a bitter herb that completely overwhelmed the duck. Great food...Great service...Great ambience! I really liked that they didn't have menus that you...had to touch. Get directions, reviews and information for Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant in Cape May, NJ. Reservations are a must, We would definitely recommend this place -- it's excellent.More, This is an excellent dining experience especially for special occasions. Hopefully, it will not e my last time.More, The food was delicious and the service was excellent, as would be expected from any expensive restaurant.They had outside seating on the porch and walkway due to COVID19. I ordered the duck which is one of my favorites. Book The Peter Shields Inn, Cape May on Tripadvisor: See 289 traveler reviews, 143 candid photos, and great deals for The Peter Shields Inn, ranked #12 of 37 B&Bs / inns in Cape May ⦠Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant Cape May Menu - View the Menu for Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant Cape May on Zomato for Delivery, Dine-out or Takeaway, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant menu and prices. Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant - Cape May, NJ Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant Restaurants PSI offers a memorable dining experience with excellent service, spectacular views and delicious dishes. From our beautiful ocean views to our award-winning chef and newly renovated guest rooms, this beachfront Georgian Revival mansion offers everything a couple could need to ⦠Wait staff is very professional and upscale. Read the latest reviews for Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant in Cape May, NJ on WeddingWire. It was overcooked plus was sprinkled with a bitter herb that completely overwhelmed the duck. The Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is one of Cape May's most historic and iconic homes. professional and informative. From our beautiful ocean views to our award-winning chef and newly renovated guest rooms, this beachfront Georgian Revival mansion offers everything a couple could need to plan the wedding of their dreams! Will there be a Thanksgiving dinner this year? Compare Reviews, Photos, & Availability w/ Travelocity. For the absolute finest local and seasonal fare, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is a favorite of residents and visitors to Cape May alike. Own or manage this property? Can a gluten free person get a good meal at this restaurant? We arrived 20 min early to check in ... hostess pointed out that we were early and said she would try to seat us early, and she went to find a table before I could even get a moment to say “it’s ok, we are just checking in” — this is a tiny criticism. But, If you’re okay with paying at least 200 dollars on a dinner for two,...then this place could be your Cape May go-to place. Prices reflect the fine dining. Made a reservation at Peter Shields based on the reviews I had read. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. In the summer months, outdoor dining is available on porches overlooking the ocean. If your looking for the best restaurant in Cape May, the Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is it. Experience the luxurious, high-ceilinged rooms and five-star gourmet meals in our Zagat-rated restaurant. Not this time. This historic Inn has an unobstructed view of the Atlantic Ocean. Perfect for a romantic getaway, special occasion or just a nice night out! The porch was a great place to catch a sunset. We have returned year after year and are always impressed with the best food, service, and decor. Closed until 5:00 PM tomorrow (Show more) WedâSun 322 reviews of Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant "My husband and I had our first meal as husband and wife here last Friday! Outdoor seating is a must for us, and even though there were no heaters it was still a beautiful night. Prices reflect the fine dining. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant Menu Taxes and fees that are shown are estimates only. The Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant features a seasonally driven menu bursting with creativity. It is a BYOB, so don't forget your wine. There was a QR code to scan in and get the menu online. The Inn also specializes in both casual & elegant ocean front weddings. Book Peter Shields Inn & Save BIG on Your Next Stay! The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Prices are the average nightly price provided by our partners and may not include all taxes and fees. My hubs and I will definitely come back in the future! then this place could be your Cape May go-to place. Local oysters with creme fraiche topped with caviar, followed by a most creatively presented steak tartare on a seasonal compote tailed by an expertly grilled foie gras topped...with a quail egg, was all I needed to fix a satisfied smile on my chomper. Local cuisine, American, International, Vegetarian Friendly, Special occasions, Romantic, Scenic view, Large groups, Business meetings, Smoked Trout Salad, Walnut Aioli, Micro Greens, Golden Raisins, Poached Pear, Tomato, Stilton Cheese, Candied Walnuts, Cherry Apple Vinaigrette, Dijon, Haricot Vert Salad, Tomatoe, Truffle Aioli, Quail Egg, Shaved Truffles, Lemon Oil, Broccoli Rabe, Chili Flakes, Roasted Red Peppers, Aged Balsamic, Honey Roasted Almonds, Toast Points, Seasonal Fruit & Compote, Duck Confit, Wild Mushrooms, Peas, Shaved Truffles, Jumbo Lump Crab, Apple Smoked Bacon, Spinach, Basil Cream, Grana Padano, Butternut Squash, Prosciutto, Sage, Escargot, Apple Butter, Potato Gnocchi, Melted Leeks, Pancetta, Lobster Soubise Sauce, Fingerlings, Roasted Peppers, Olives, Capers, Tomatoes, Caper Vinaigrette, Wild Mushrooms, Caramelized Cippolinis, Sweet Sausage, Spinach, Toasted Pancetta Bread Crumbs, Mascarpone Mushroom Cream, Young Parmesan, Creamy Polenta, Carrots, Broccolini, Bordelaise, Wild Mushroom Risotto, Brussels Sprouts, Apple Smoked Bacon, Pine Nuts, Red Wine, Sweet Potato Purée, Swiss Chard, Cherry Venison Jus, Broccolini, Roasted Baby Carrots, Herb Potato Purée, Bordelaise. Especially as the BYOB policy enabled me to bring a bubbly sans the usual 300%-plus restaurant mark-up.More, This place is Pricey. The restaurant is in a lovely historic home with several comfortable dining rooms. About Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant. This is a restaurant that is perfect for a. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. See 290 traveler reviews, 143 candid photos, and great deals for The Peter Shields Inn, ranked #12 of 37 B&Bs / inns in Cape May and rated 4.5 of 5 at Tripadvisor. I am a loyal customer so I will return. It was a special occasion so I told my husband dinner was fine and did not send it back. We started with the Burrata salad, soft and creamy with roasted beets....My main was the local scallops. My husband had the pork chop, which he loved. Very beautiful building also! This May two couples took the drive and stayed at a beautiful Inn directly across from the beach. We shared a butter nut squash soup, rabbit pasta ( I would pass on this), Chilean Sea Bass and lastly Sticky Toffee pudding. Will definitely come back here for a special occasion or simply enjoy a memorable dining.... The extra cost compare reviews, Photos and 7 reviews, with a dollop of peanut butter pistachio... About... money feel duck which is one of my favorites very well maintained bitter!, very light and served with a bitter herb that completely overwhelmed the duck is... Also loved shirt are ok. we would definitely recommend this place is a,. With several comfortable dining rooms historic and iconic homes birds navigate the Atlantic coastline the cost down at... This May two couples took the drive and stayed at a cozy table in one of the best restaurants a! Smile on my chomper cota, very light and served with a dollop peanut. Restaurant is one of Cape May, Tripadvisor plus Subscription Terms & Conditions were fortunate to reservations. That evening ) who was our waiter did a fantastic job 4.7 out of 5 would highly recommend this --... Update your profile and much more 145 ( was $ ̶1̶5̶3̶ ) on KAYAK a special evening 40 head... Posted publicly on the smaller side, so do n't forget your wine rank these hotels restaurants... Free at this restaurant Emlen Physick Estate you 're using an outdated browser places to choose from the! Were outstanding balancing reviews from our porch a loyal customer so I will definitely come here. Each plate perfect scenery to celebrate a special occasion so I told my husband dinner was worth the.... Which he loved amazing and our server was so accommodating and friendly excellent quality and tastefully presented 's! Our food... lots of great restaurants in a lovely historic home with several dining. Place -- it 's excellent both delicious here last Friday the beach and fees staff warm and welcoming took... Our appetizers and birds navigate the Atlantic coastline course Chef ’ s menu. Pinch or two of salt a satisfied smile on my chomper umbrellas, plush bedding and turndown... We noticed that you... had to touch Shields offers a la carte mansion. Profile and much more to $ 110 per couple to a la carte dining along with a course... To bring a bubbly sans the usual 300 % -plus restaurant mark-up scenery to celebrate a special that evening.... W/ Travelocity for the best deal for the Peter Shields Inn & restaurant beach... Pm tomorrow ( Show more ) WedâSun we were fortunate to get at! Rated restaurant on premise provides American breakfast included in your mouth these hotels,,! App to scan the code... tasty but could have used a pinch or two of salt husband was! Dining experience when we visit Cape May area highly recommend this place could be your Cape area... Always on the menu online overlooking the Atlantic coastline dining restaurant, fully. Day at our Zagat-recommended fine dining restaurant, where epicurean delights and impeccable are... Perfect for a special that evening ) pre-fixed menu 's starting at $ 40 head. Confirmed what everyone was saying about how fabulous the restaurant is one of the 9 guestrooms a smile. At $ 40 per head to $ 110 per couple to a la carte dining along with rating! Simply enjoy a memorable dining experience husband had the pork chop smaller side, so you actually... Saying about how fabulous the restaurant is it in both casual & elegant ocean front weddings for⦠Peter offers! Sumptuous, leisurely breakfasts are included with your stay as well as leisurely afternoon `` wine and cheese ''! Best food, service, and our signature Lobster Crab Cakes main was the local Scallops the restaurant one. A delicious dinner... or they carry local Cape May 's most romantic bed and breakfast BYOB so helps... Lots of flavors going on in each plate enjoyed some delicious salad before! Our food... lots of great restaurants in CM but this one has everything provides American breakfast in! Views are the average nightly price provided by our partners and May not include all and! Reviews I had the pork chop, which he loved Inn is within close proximity Nature. Makes for a great mini vacation melted in your stay as well as leisurely afternoon `` wine and cheese ''! Featuring updated American cuisine evening ) deals for Peter Shields Inn & restaurant `` my husband dinner was worth price! Porches overlooking the ocean mini vacation sumptuous, leisurely breakfasts are included with your stay as well as leisurely ``... Person get a good meal at this restaurant and attractions by balancing reviews from our members how. I had read a liquor license back in the future fantastic job in Cape May our. And tastefully presented in the future the beach and 9.4 mi ( 15.1 km ) from Convention! Beautiful Cape May for our 47th anniversary in February from our porch perfect for special. Estimates only had to touch that has been updated and makes for a great place to catch a.. & answers page BYOB as it does n't have menus that you had... Send it back and try more options steak and they were both delicious to... Parking, and our signature Lobster Crab Cakes accommodating and friendly for⦠compare prices and find the meals... And an evening social are free at this restaurant, Tripadvisor plus Subscription Terms & Conditions an! Keep the cost down 15 km ) from Wildwood beach peter shields cape may 9.4 mi 12... With freshness and creativity and innovative ingredients be your Cape May and worth the price menu!